C.S. Lewis is credited as having once remarked that "integrity is doing the right thing even when no one is watching." His observation seemingly cuts to the heart of what true moral character means – not just appearing good to impress others, but embodying goodness even in the most private of moments.
So, what does it really mean to "do the right thing," and why should we care when, in some circumstances, no one would ever know the difference?
The Concept of Right Action
Doing the right thing often seems simple on the surface – tell the truth, keep your promises, share your sweets, help others in need and keep the cub scout law.
In practice though, our ethical decisions frequently involve competing values and complicated trade-offs. The person at the till gives you too much change; you fudge some numbers on your taxes; a friend tells you something that could help someone else in trouble: in these moments, integrity demands we think beyond mere rules to understand our deeper principles.
Some would argue that the most useful framework, one that I was taught as a child, is the well known imperative – acting in ways that you would want everyone else to act in similar situations.
It's biblical, though it stems from plenty of other religious scripts too.
It's also evolutionary, in that it benefits the pack or the tribe if we give up or sacrifice something of our own for the sake of the safety or benefit of everyone else - the greater good.
Who Are You Doing the Right Thing By?
We often talk about "doing the right thing" as if it's straightforward – as if there's always a binary right and wrong choice. But some of life's hardest decisions come when doing the right thing by others means potentially doing the wrong thing to ourselves. These moments force us to wrestle with competing moral obligations: our duty to others and our duty to who we are.
Imagine a talented software engineer discovering that their dream job was being advertised at another company when the timing couldn't have been worse. Their current team was in the middle of a critical project, and their departure would leave their current team seriously understaffed. Their manager had been incredibly supportive, giving them opportunities when they were just starting out and mentoring them throughout their career. The team had become like family.
They knew they could stick around for another six months to finish the project. It would be the loyal thing to do and the kind thing to do - they'd be a team player.
However, this dream role might not be available at the end of the six months.
Should they be obligated to sacrifice their career advancement for the good of their current team? Do they owe it to themselves to pursue their dreams, even if it meant letting others down?
These dilemmas show up in personal relationships too.
You can spend years building up a small business while caring for your aging mother. When your mum needs full-time care, you can face an impossible choice. Hiring professional help would mean taking on debt that could sink your business. Moving your mother to a nursing home can feel like betrayal. Taking on the care yourself would mean giving up the business you've worked so hard to build.
These kinds of conflict often set our long-term wellbeing and our immediate obligations to others up against each other.
There's no clean solution, no choice that doesn't involve some form of sacrifice or compromise.
These situations are especially challenging because they force us to confront complicated questions about what we actually owe to others and what we owe to ourselves.
Most of us grow up learning that selflessness is virtuous and putting others first is good. Taken to an extreme, though, this mindset can lead to self-neglect or even self-destruction.
The Personal Cost of Integrity
Living with integrity isn't easy. It often means: passing up opportunities for personal gain; having difficult conversations instead of comfortable silence; admitting mistakes that no one would have discovered; standing up for what's right even when it costs us socially.
These choices can feel especially painful when we see others taking shortcuts ethically, but still prospering. A voice in our minds says to us: "Everyone else does it," "No one will know," or "You deserve this."
If we have integrity, it can demand we resist these urges.
The Hidden Benefits of Integrity
Integrity can offer profound personal benefits that might offset its costs. When we consistently do what's right, we might develop genuine self-respect and dignity. We can also avoid the psychological burden of maintaining lies and pretence. Trust can be built in our relationships. As a result, we sleep better at night as we don't have so many thoughts running through our heads. If, in our own minds, we get it all right, we can become the kind of person we admire.
It could be said, therefore and possibly most importantly, that integrity shapes who we fundamentally are. Each choice to do right or wrong moulds our character. Over time, these choices determine not just what we do, but who we become.
The Societal Impact
While individual acts of integrity may seem small, their cumulative effect on society is huge. Trust, cooperation, and social capital all depend on people doing the right thing even when they could get away with doing the wrong one. A society of integrity is one where:
Contracts are honoured
Public and resources are protected
The vulnerable are helped
Justice is served
Progress is possible
When integrity fails, these systems break down. Corruption, fraud, and abuse of power create inefficiency and suffering that harm everyone.
The Choice Before Us
Every day presents moments where we must choose between integrity and expedience. While the right path isn't always clear, the commitment to finding and following it must be unwavering.
True integrity goes beyond following rules when others are watching. It means doing right because it is right – because that's who we are and who we want to be. In a world of increasing surveillance, perhaps the last true test of character is what we do in those moments when we could get away with less.
The choice to live with integrity may cost us in the short term. But it builds something priceless: a life we can be proud of and a world that works for everyone. As C.S. Lewis understood, our private choices shape not only our own character but the very fabric of society.
And perhaps doing right by others and doing right by ourselves aren't mutually exclusive every time – sometimes we just need to look harder for solutions that serve both. Sometimes, if we don't do the right thing by ourselves, we can't do good by others. We shouldn't automatically assume that self-sacrifice is the more moral choice.
Perhaps the real wisdom lies in understanding that taking care of ourselves isn't selfish – it's what enables us to keep showing up for others in a more sustainable way.
The trick is finding that delicate balance where we can look in the mirror and feel we're doing right by everyone, including ourselves.
If you’d like to find out more about the coaching work we could do together which could be related to integrity in any kind of situation, click on my website link below:
Alternatively, you can book a discovery call here:
Comments